Journalism,
Mr.Kefor
January
20th
Modern Day Discrimination?
Driving is one of the most common things
we as people do in our everyday lives. Pretty early on we learn
to operate on the roads and although most of us are adequate drivers insurance
is necessary for all of us. Insurance is expensive: but why in our modern day
society, where equality is what everyone is all about are men paying more for
insurance from the very beginning? Shouldn’t we all be treated as individuals
and not be stereotyped by the labels of society? Insurance companies think not.
Are they wrong to think this way, or is it in fact discrimination? That’s
exactly what we’re going to explore.
Stereotypes
are one thing but number don’t lie. A National
Department of Transportation study entitled "Sex of Drivers Involved in
Crashes 2000-2009" found that male drivers were involved in some 18
million more accidents than female drivers during the same time frame. Not only
do men get into more car accidents, but men also are more commonly involved in
speeding, alcohol and other major accidents, whereas women are more likely to
be in a fender bender here and there. The bigger the accident the less
insurance companies like you. "Insurance companies see men as a bigger
risk, they don’t like that." (Loose 1). Loose is basically saying that if
you're male you need to suck it up. Men have been paying higher insurance
premiums for the last half a century and that’s how it's going to be.
"But if a man and a
woman living in the same city with the same profile shop for car insurance, the
woman would likely receive a lower auto insurance quote."(Roberts-Grey
1). It seems like pretty simple logic right? You drive recklessly and you pay
more for insurance. According to the National Highway Traffic Safety
Administration, more than 70% of the people involved in fatal car crashes in
2009 were men. But this only makes sense, considering that approximately
65% of road drivers are in fact men. More male drivers equals more male car
accidents right? If you take all the male and female crashes and compare them
to the total amount of crashes on the road you'll see something quite
interesting. Male crashes compared to female crashes are at an almost 1:1
ratio. Although, even with this amazing piece of information it does not change
the fact that men are still involved in much more reckless driving then women. According
to a study by Quality Planning, a San Francisco company that validates
policyholder information for auto insurers, male drivers are also cited for
reckless driving 3.4 times more than women are. 3.4 times doesn't seem
anything like a 1:1 Ratio. If men are that much more reckless I'm surprised
insurance companies haven't found a way to get more money out of us!
According
to a Accurate auto investigation annual reporting does not take into account
the fact that men drive more miles than women, on average and therefore are
"exposed" to traffic situations more often. Why are men being charged
so much for insurance then? Well, their younger less experienced male brethren
are to blame for that. Males under the age of 25 are seen as "high
risk" because of their frequent involvement in car accidents, speeding,
and road rage. This statement applies to my life completely. Before even having
my license for 6 months I managed to wrap myself around a pole, and take out a
mail box. Both on separate occasions and entirely due to speeding. "Men of
any age group are far more likely to be driving while intoxicated, to speed, to
drive recklessly, and to flout the law. They also tend to drive cars that give
them psychological boost to commit these violations more often."(AAI 1).
Male car choice seems to play a large role in high
insurance rates as well. Whereas females are more likely to drive a safe, fuel efficient
cars. Men are more likely to drive a racecar type vehicle. I personally can
attest to this. Being an owner of a Bmw 335xi I cannot lie when I say that is
speed far more now than I did when I drove my vw jetta. Going from 150 bhp
(Horsepower) to 306 fuel guzzling horses under the hood of your car not only
gives you an ego boost but quite a heavy foot as well. Luckily I am yet to get
pulled over, but I find myself driving over 100mph on the highway quite
frequently. BAD HABIT. Woman, and mothers in particular drive vehicles for
child transportation, (minivans), which gives them a little less of a
"rush" compared to what most men drive. When you're moving kids
around from one place to another, chances are you're not going to put the
family tree on the line for a quick thrill.
So
basically, men pay for more insurance not because they get into more car
accidents, speed more, get more citations etc.. Those all apply, but mostly
because of the types of car accidents they are getting into. Whereas women are
playing bumper cars, men are more inclined to drink a beer or two and wrap
themselves around a tree, or maybe a nice aluminum pole. If men got into the
same types of accidents as women, their insurance rates wouldn’t be nearly as
high. Although, even if men didn't get into as many reckless incidents it doesn’t
change the fact that we speed, and overall are less rational on the roads. With
all the stated, is it fair? Is it discrimination for men to pay more for auto
insurance even though they are statistically "worse" drivers? My
personal answer is yes. In a society where everything is about equality and
treating people as equals it seems that car insurance companies haven't caught
up with the pack. Drivers should be charged based on their driving history not
gender. Sure, men may be more likely to speed statistically.. but if a man has
no speeding tickets why are you going to charge him more for something he might
do? I don’t see people going to jail for maybe in the future committing a
felony. This logic is flawed and is
simply a way for big business to get more money out of the common man.
Loose, Terence.
"Auto Insurance Article." Yahoo! Auto Insurance. Yahoo, n.d. Web. 21 Jan. 2014.
"Are Car Insurers
Unfair to Men?" MSNMoney. Msn,
n.d. Web. 21 Jan. 2014.
"Get Your
Quote." Accurate Auto Insurance RSS. Accurate Auto Insurance, n.d. Web. 21 Jan. 2014.